Showing posts with label five broken cameras. Show all posts
Showing posts with label five broken cameras. Show all posts

Saturday, February 4, 2012

a series of juxtapositions: a review of five broken cameras



about suffering they were never wrong,
the old masters: how well they understood
its human position: how it takes place
while someone else is eating or opening a window or just walking dully along;


begins w. h. auden's poem musee des beax arts.


the documentary five broken cameras begins with a juxtapostion of images that highlights the suffering experienced by the villagers of bil'in,  a tiny village on the west bank.  in addition to heartbreaking tragedy, though, we also see the surprising amount of joy and hope the citizens of bil'in manage to maintain even under siege.  the ability of directors emad burnat and guy davidi to portray this seemingly indestructable core of hope and happiness the villagers of bil'in sustain against an overwhelmingly armed and organized israeli army is the great strength of this documentary.  the captivating images and characters in the film make us stop and care about the plight of these people, unable to continue "walking dully along."

we see, in the opening moments of the film, thousand year-old olive trees being upended by a bulldozer.  a thousand years of growth destroyed before we can blink.  in a way it is one of the most powerful and sickening images in the film--the destruction of the olive tree with all it's attendant metaphorical and literal associations.  these trees are the life-blood of the villagers, who make their living from the land, as well as the symbol of peace, prosperity and humanity.  in one scene, a villager wraps his arms and legs around the tree and grins.  the tree looks as comfortable being embraced by the villager as a mother.  and we feel that the tree is as important to the village as a mother.

in another scene, where an entire grove of trees is being burned, a villager wails in a moving voice-over:  this tree praying to god--how could you burn it?  in another instance, little gibreel, burnat's son, toddles up to an israeli soldier and hands him an olive branch.  in yet another, the villagers carry tiny potted trees to re-plant the groves that have been destroyed past impassive armed soldiers.  the olive tree is so heavy with symbolism that these small gestures could seem over-wrought.  but the constant contextualization of the trees and their importance to the people and the land re-roots this familiar symbol, helps viewers to remember and appreciate the origins of it's powerful associations as not only symbol, but as literal sustenance.

though this could have been a film about weeping and wailing, the beautiful surprise of it was the joy and exuberance the villagers displayed in their protests; in the face of tear gas, stun grenades, and m-16's, the village men march with toy instruments borrowed from their children's play things, or "el phil", one of the leaders in the resistance, tall, broad and handsome, almost like the village hercules, running along the barrier flying a kite in the face of the soldiers.  or the group of village boys, skinny as young saplings, swaggering towards the barrier.

we're going to get our land back, one confident boy, no more than 12 years-old, proclaims.

burnat and davidi were smart to continuously place the small, vulnerable, sometimes funny and clever, gestures of the resisters in this unevenly matched battle against the armored vehicles, heavily armed and armored soldiers, and barbed wire.  or the stunningly rugged  hills dotted with beautiful trees set against the back drop of the horrible, cheap construction of the new israeli settlements.

at the beginning of the film, i was somewhat skeptical of the central conceit of it--burnat tells his story by focusing around the lives of his five cameras, broken in the resistance, with which he used to document six years of protest. i was worried at first that this could be merely a high concept gimmick used to market the film, but it turned out that the cameras actually seemed to evolve into characters in the film. it turned out that burnat, who was the cameraman, director, and also subject of the film, was making a crucial point about witnessing, telling, and recording.

the victim's only obligation is to heal. . . i film so i can heal, he says towards the end of the film.

the filming of this struggle, a gesture that appears to have begun as one of burnat's small points of resistance,  has become a larger gesture as the film has gone out into the world.  it has since won awards at festivals and been signed for distribution.

i saw the film in an auditorium filled with utah teenagers in salt lake city at the sundance film festival during a special high school screening.  at the end of the film, the kids gave burnat, davidi and the film a standing ovation.  how did you not fight back?  were any of the soldiers kind?  how did you feel about your sons growing up like this?  do you still live there?  what can american teens do to help? the high-schoolers asked.  they were clearly moved and compelled to do something to alleviate the suffering of the villagers of bil'in, as evidenced by this unusually long question and answer session at the end of the screening.

auden knew that "the human position of suffering" has to be relegated to a dark and humble corner, has to take place while someone else is eating, or opening a window, or walking dully along. In order for humans to survive, to retain sanity, it seems we have to look away from suffering, to tell ourselves that everything is okay in the world.

five broken cameras accomplished the complex and virtuosic feat of making us stop to observe and empathize while at the same time acknowledging that, as long as the small human gestures of resistance continue in the face of an overfunded overgrown machine of aggression against basic humanity, it will still, somehow, some day, be okay.

Friday, January 27, 2012

cameras, bones, holey tights, the road to jericho

once again, i have way too many things to say.

i saw the very strong documentary film five broken cameras today at the sundance film festival, and am in the process of writing a complete review to post here in the next day or two.
still from five broken cameras

but once again, this film hit me hard with the truth: that when we cease to see individuals and see groups/races/castes/genders/religions/preferences instead of the wounded individual on the road to jericho who needs us to pour oil and wine into his wounds, the world is an effed up place.

on the way home from the film, we stopped at les madeleines for their much lauded kouing-aman pastry.  this pastry is not over-hyped.  it's for real, and worth the $5.50 a pop, the long line you have to wait in, and the attitude they give you behind the counter.  if you're in salt lake city, i would for sure put this place on your list.

kouing-aman pastry from les madeleines


also, i began gabrielle hamilton's memoir blood, bones, and butter.  i've been very excited about this book, as it feeds into my obsession with chefs, food writing, prune, and drama.  i was not disappointed in chapter one.  check this out:

just started this--chapter one is a thumbs up


"prying back the lid on a fifty-gallon barrel of silver glitter--the kind that took two men and a hand truck to wheel into the paint supply room of the shop--and then shoving your hands down into it up to your elbows is an experince that will secure the idea in your heart for the rest of your live that your dad is, himself, the greatest show on earth. (p. 9)"

legwear:  charcoal cheetah tights.  one hole over each big toe now.  wonder how many more wearings i'll get?  the holes are still small enough that i can scooch them over to the side of each big toe and pretend they're not there.  once they slip down over the toes, i think i'll make like my friend, style-maven andi p-d, and cut out the crotch and off the feet, ballerina style, and wear them as false & fitted sleeves. under any and everything, like andi p-d, who looks fabulous 24-7.

does anyone out there have any good holey tights stories?

and if your tights have holes, post a comment here to win some super-duper fancy new ones.

inspiration:  glitter, witnessing, being willing to die for what you believe in.

looking forward: dinner date with husband--love friday night for this!!!!!!! will report on where we go later.


Wednesday, January 25, 2012

gay 90's, funeral potatoes & sundance

beth snow andersen whitaker evans
there are many things to say today, but i will try to limit them to three.

first, and definitely most important, is celebrating my transcendent grandmother, beth snow andersen whitaker evans, who is 90 years old today.

wow.

it's hard to know where to begin with her, but i think i'll just tell one little story that's relevant to this blog.  i'll try not to cry while i write it, and you try not to cry when you read it.

when grandma was five, her mother died of sepsis after giving birth to her eigth child in emory, utah.  she was sent to live with relatives in st. george, and the money for her care was kept in a tea cup on top of the ice box.  grandma recalls the lady of the house taking down the tea cup and pursing her lips in displeasure whenever she had to take money from the (what my grandma believed) too small allowance.

when spring came, which is hot in st. george, grandma was still wearing her long woolen stockings.  how she longed for white cotton anklets like the other girls wore to school.  so she asked the lady of the house if she could have some.  the lady replied, "your other mother can buy them for you when you return to emory in the summer." (grandma's father had just remarried.)

so grandma had to keep wearing the long stockings for the duration of the school year.  she reports that when she returned to emory, her greeting to her new step-mother was, "can i have some anklets?"  her step-mother said, "of course."
gramdma beth at the homestead

and it seems that things took a happier turn in this tragic year from that moment on.  but it's clear that grandma has held this incident close, and she makes it her practice to "never say no."  this might mean that when my children ask grandma for a sleepover, she'll say, "why, yes, we will have to work on scheduling that sometime."  and that might mean next friday, or it could mean that grandma is thinking,  in parentheses, that she will hold said sleepover some day after she has been resurrected from the grave and feels up to it again.  either way, her ability to make a child feel loved, accepted, and attended to is legendary.

i love and respect this lady more than i can possibly say.

and p.s.--she used to draw lines up the backs of her fantastic legs during the war when stockings were scarce.

secondly, i went to sundance last night with a friend who had a press pass and therefore invites to the exclusive parties.  i did my darndest to network, hand out cards, talk up my script, etc.  but i'm so gosh darn bad at it.  it felt hideous the whole time.  is there such thing as a person i could hire to be me and pimp my work for me?

me and lorri at bing bar--me trying to act natural
if schmoozing around a bunch of other schmoozers is  what it takes to get your work out there, i'll surely just moulder in my stocking drawer for the rest of my days.

i heard great things about another earth and the turkish film (the first one ever at sundance) can,  and one friend raved about west of memphis.  i'm trying to get in to see the artist is present about marina abramovic tomorrow night, then i'll be seeing five broken cameras on friday.  i have best of fest tickets for a week from monday (free for locals!)


alas, no celeb sightings.

favorite provo restaurant
the ny times featured an article yesterday on mormon cuisine, mentioning my favorite provo restaurant, communal, and the fact that a lot of mormons have retained "basic homemaking skills"  that much of the country has lost.  this is something i love about my culture.  we still have a strong, some might say religious even, pull to the dinner table.

i'm all about that.
 
here is the "updated funeral potato" recipe from the nyt and an old post on funeral potatoes from my old blog.


legwear:  today it's frigid and i'm wearing grey jeans.  don't forget to enter in our tights giveaway.  we selected some beautiful, warm and pretty fancy tights for some lucky legs out there.

inspiration:  never say no.

looking forward:  to more sundance.